-So! Where are you from?
Oh crap... here we are again.
Oh crap... here we are again.
As years passed I worked on the best answer I could possibly give to this apparently silly question. All the places where I've travelled to, the ones in which I've actually stayed for a while, in which I've lived, studied, been to the grocery's and missed the bus are where I am from. So I go:“I used to be from Italy...now I'm from Barcelona - I guess”.That's how I keep people on the hook. Either that or they just ignore my answer and look at me as if I grew up in a cocoon of self-banishment.
Anyhow, being a TEFL teacher in Barcelona doesn't really make me Spanish, or should I say Catalan? That's exactly where I wanted to get to. Last autumn I set off to Barcelona, thinking that I was heading to Spain. I moved there and I was thrilled, or to use one of the many untranslatable Spanish words I had tons of “ilusión”. For you who have lived in Barcelona and who have stumbled across this post, you might notice the oddly high frequency of 'Spain' related words. As a matter of fact the less you pronounce the word Spain in Catalonia, the better you live. Politics, scandals, ailing and stagnant economy plus poor education and health care system services contributed to the encouragement for independence.
Sadly enough this also resulted in a cultural war for independence using Catalan as a show of strength and support for the same cause. As many of you might already know Catalonia, as many other Spanish regions, suffered from a terrible cultural and language repression during the Francoist dictatorship which lasted almost 40 years. During that time no language could be spoked other than Castilian (aka Spanish). In 1975 when this nonsense finally came to an end, Catalonia, who was deeply hurt by years and years of cultural repression, became very sensible when it came to protecting its cultural legacy. Since then, Catalan has been lingua franca and working language in Catalonia which left a mere second language role to Castilian Spanish.
Barcelona is the only city in Catalonia where people say there is somehow still bilingualism. Be it due to tourism, be it due to mass immigration. Many people I know say that outside Barcelona there is a great amount of people who don't really speak Castilian as fluent as they are supposed to. Why? Because they don't need it. At least inside this county. I teach kids, many kids, they go to Catalan schools, they speak Catalan among them, they speak Catalan at home. By the age of 6 they still make easy mistakes in Spanish such as 'decido' instead of 'dicho' and 'ponido' instead of 'puesto'. Such mistakes should disappear past the age of 4. Some others can only understand Spanish but they can't really speak it, or that's what their parents say at least.
I always feel pensive when it comes to choosing up sides. Is it understandable or over the top? Do I like it or not? What would I do? I have no clue. It's something that goes beyond me, in which I should have no say because even though I feel like I belong here the community looks down on you until you actually pick a side. Their side. And to do that you ought to speak their language. Which is not really one of the easiest for that matter. So as a foreigner you are not supposed to have your opinion until you support the cause for independence. Which is not only for political grounds but also, allegedly, for cultural reasons.
As a teacher I think the saddest thing of all is that the claim for cultural respect turned a language into a shield and a cultural barrier. A barrier which should have been knocked down as Franco died but was instead rebuilt by a local counter-part and almost turned into a discrimination against the second worldwide most spoken language. Want it or not, Spanish extremely useful and kids should be mastering it. This by no means implies the neglect of the Catalan language in school, at home or wherever.I guess we will have to wait and see what happens if they ever manage to do a referendum and decide for their own fate, which sounds reasonable in what should be a free country.